Link copied
The neon lights buzzed overhead as the wooden dance floor buckled beneath the shuffle of gliding boots to blaring country music over the speakers. Most might have been content to sit idle, with a cold beer in hand, to watch the action from the sidelines. But John had confidence. And more importantly, he had the urge to move.
At 45 or 50 years old, the grizzled highway patrolman spotted a 25-year-old cowgirl across the bar and decided to make his move. He jumped from his seat, tossed a knowing look back at his buddies and crossed the room to ask her to dance.
She turned him down.
John made his way back to the group with the kind of news that invites interrogation from a table full of men. “She says she doesn't dance”, he said to ease the impact of their immediate commentary. Fair enough. For about 15 minutes, the explanation held.
Then a young cowboy walked through the door.
Whatever objection the cowgirl had to dancing apparently disappeared. Before long, she and the cowboy were out on the floor together, leaving John at the mercy of a table of friends who had just witnessed the whole thing. The jokes came quicker than John’s machismo could handle. Then one of the men landed the line that mattered. “John, I guess you should have been a cowboy”, he said with a wink. Everybody laughed. But somewhere at that table, a young singer-songwriter, obsessed with the West and Gunsmoke, was listening.
His name was Toby Keith.
The scribbles across a few cocktail napkins started to take shape. He began with, "I bet you've never heard ol' Marshal Dillon say, Miss Kitty, have you ever thought of runnin' away?" immortalizing the famed Gunsmoke characters in a song that would introduce them to yet another generation.
From there, Keith let his own Western fantasies run wild. Cowboys and six-shooters, cattle drives and romance, Jesse James and riding off into the sunset all found their way onto the crumpled napkins. With each line, he carved a path through a terracotta-soaked Western landscape, inviting anyone listening to saddle up alongside him and live out their own dreams of roping, riding and disappearing into the horizon.
A highway patrolman had been turned down for a dance and twenty minutes later, Toby Keith had his debut single ‘Should’ve Been a Cowboy.’ When it finally rode onto Country Radio in 1993, it arrived without much fanfare. The song entered the Hot Country Songs chart at No. 69 on March 6th, dismissed as another hopeful debut from another unknown singer trying to find his place in Nashville.
Then it started to climb.
Week after week, Keith's little Western fantasy traveled farther. By June 5th, ‘Should've Been a Cowboy’ had reached No. 1, where it remained for two weeks. A joke tossed across a barroom table had somehow escaped into the American imagination.
And it never really left.
Over the next three decades, the song followed Keith from promising newcomer to country superstar, becoming inseparable from the man who wrote it. In September 2023, 30 years after its release, ‘Should've Been a Cowboy’ was certified triple-platinum, proof that the cowboy Keith imagined on those cocktail napkins was still riding.
Then, on February 5th, 2024, Toby Keith passed away from a fearless battle with stomach cancer.
In the days that followed, listeners returned to the songs he left behind. Five of them rode back onto the country chart, but none climbed higher than the one that had started everything. ‘Should've Been a Cowboy’ returned to Hot Country Songs at No. 12.
A song about wanting to be something you're not, dreaming of somewhere you've never been and wondering whether life might have turned out differently if you'd taken another road. Keith may have written about cowboys, but he sang for the people sitting on the barstools. The workers, the dreamers, the brokenhearted and the overlooked who could hear a little of themselves in his songs.
Toby Keith dreamed in the language of the everyman. He gave melody to ordinary lives and larger-than-life desires, creating songs where people could recognize who they were and imagine who they might still become. As long as there are dreamers, wondering about the road not taken, there will be a Toby Keith song waiting to ride along with them.
